Why Selling Your Life Insurance in Retirement May Cost You More Than You Think

Umbrella protecting coins and a document, illustrating the risks of selling life insurance in retirement

If you’re nearing retirement or already in it, there’s a good chance someone has pitched you on the idea of selling your life insurance policy. The ads make it sound simple: you no longer need the coverage, the premiums are a drag on your budget, and a company is ready to hand you a lump sum today. Why not take the cash and enjoy it?

I understand why that sounds appealing. But in our experience, selling a policy, which the industry calls a life settlement, is a decision that deserves a lot more scrutiny than the sales pitch suggests. For many people, there are better ways to solve the problem. Here’s what we want you to know before you pick up the phone.

What a life settlement actually is

In a life settlement, you sell your policy to a third-party investor for more than the policy’s cash surrender value but less than the death benefit. The buyer takes over the premiums and collects the full death benefit when you pass away. In other words, the buyer is making a bet on how long you will live, and they only make money if the price they pay is low enough to leave room for a profit.

That last part is the key. The buyer needs to come out ahead, which means you almost always receive well under what your family would have received had you simply held on to the policy.

What this means for you: The offer on the table is not the value of your policy. It’s the price an investor is willing to pay while still earning a return on your life expectancy. Those two numbers can be very far apart.

The payout is usually a fraction of the death benefit

One industry estimate puts typical settlements at roughly 12% to 25% of the death benefit, with higher offers generally reserved for people with serious health conditions and low premiums. Brokers and providers also take fees and commissions along the way, which reduces what ends up in your pocket.

To make that concrete, consider a hypothetical: a $500,000 policy that you’re no longer excited about paying for. A settlement offer might come in at a fraction of that. If you kept the policy, your beneficiaries would eventually receive the full $500,000 income-tax-free, in most cases. If you sell, they receive nothing from that policy. (This example is hypothetical and for illustration only. Actual offers vary widely based on age, health, policy type and cost.)

What this means for you: Before you sell, ask what the policy is worth to your family, not just what it’s worth to a buyer. If you have a spouse or children who would benefit from that tax-free death benefit, that’s a large trade-off to make for a one-time check.

The tax bill can come as a surprise

Here’s something many sellers don’t expect. The death benefit your family would receive is generally income-tax-free. The money you receive from selling the policy generally isn’t. Part of the proceeds can be taxed as ordinary income, and part as a capital gain, depending on how the sale price compares with the premiums you’ve paid and the policy’s cash value. FINRA, the securities industry regulator, has warned that the lump sum can be taxable depending on your circumstances.

And the tax effects don’t necessarily stop at the sale itself. A large one-time increase in your income can push you into a higher bracket for the year. It can also affect how much of your Social Security benefit is taxable, and because Medicare’s IRMAA surcharges are based on your income from two years earlier, a settlement this year could mean higher Medicare premiums down the road.

What this means for you: This is exactly the kind of thing we try to plan around, whether it’s a Roth conversion in a lower-income year or timing a large transaction carefully. Selling a policy without understanding the tax picture first is how a good-looking offer turns into a disappointing one. Please talk with your advisor and a tax professional before you sign anything.

It can affect your eligibility for benefits

If there’s any chance you may need Medicaid to help with long-term care costs, be especially careful. FINRA’s investor alert notes that a settlement can negatively affect your ability to receive state or federal public assistance such as Medicaid. A lump sum of cash lands on your balance sheet differently than a life insurance policy does, and the rules around eligibility can be unforgiving.

What this means for you: Long-term care is one of the biggest financial risks in retirement. If it’s on your radar, make sure any decision about your policy is coordinated with your long-term care plan first.

You may not be able to get the coverage back

Once you sell, the coverage is gone. If your needs change later, for example if you remarry, a spouse’s situation changes, or you want to leave a legacy or cover an estate tax bill, replacing the insurance at an older age and in a different health situation can be expensive or simply not possible. The NASD, the predecessor to FINRA, flagged this exact concern in its investor alert for seniors.

Privacy and complexity

There’s also a part of the process most people don’t think about. To price your policy, buyers need your medical records. Those records can be shared with several parties as the policy is bought, sold and resold over the years, a concern raised in testimony before the U.S. Senate Special Committee on Aging. And be wary of any pitch that involves buying a new policy specifically so it can be sold later. That’s known as stranger-originated life insurance, and regulators have been warning consumers about it for years. In some states, it’s illegal.

What this means for you: Work only with properly licensed providers, and if an offer sounds too good to be true, take that seriously.

Look at the alternatives first

If the real issue is that the premiums have become a burden or you’re not sure the policy still fits, a sale is rarely the only option, and often not the best one. Before you consider selling, ask about these:

  • Reduce the death benefit. Many policies let you lower the coverage amount in exchange for lower premiums.
  • Convert to reduced paid-up coverage. On many whole life policies, you can stop paying premiums and keep a smaller death benefit in force.
  • Do a 1035 exchange. This lets you move the value of one policy into a different policy or an annuity without paying tax on the gain, including options that pay for long-term care.
  • Ask about accelerated death benefits. If you face a serious or terminal illness, your policy may allow you to access part of the death benefit while you’re living.
  • Look at the policy loan or use of cash value. In some cases, using the policy’s own value can solve a short-term cash need.

Each of these has its own trade-offs, and which one makes sense depends on the type of policy you own, its cost, and your health and goals.

When selling can make sense

To be fair, a life settlement is not always a bad idea. For someone who no longer needs the coverage, has no beneficiaries who depend on it, and would otherwise let the policy lapse for nothing, a sale can put real money back in their pocket. That’s the situation where it’s worth a serious look. But it should be the last option you evaluate, not the first, and only after you’ve compared it against everything above and run the numbers on taxes and benefits.

The bottom line

Life insurance is one of the few assets that can pass to your family income-tax-free. Selling it trades that benefit for a discounted, potentially taxable lump sum, and it’s very hard to undo. If someone is encouraging you to sell, slow down. Make sure you understand what you’d receive, what you’d give up, and what the alternatives look like.

Sources

This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered personalized investment, tax, insurance or legal advice. Life settlement and insurance decisions depend on your individual circumstances. Please consult your advisor, tax professional and, where appropriate, an attorney regarding your specific situation.

X
Facebook
LinkedIn

Related Posts

2027 Medicare premiums are set, with Part B rising to $209.40. Plus Fed minutes, a jittery market, mortgage rates and

Contact Us

Schedule a Free 15-Minute Call

Contact Us